Friday, May 23, 2014

Homage to John Repulski



JOHN REPULSKI has been a supportive colleague and an inspired contributor to the worship and ministry of Christ Church Cranbrook, and those with whom he will serve in his new position will be greatly blessed by his presence among them.
What I will miss the most about John is his capacity for musical surprise. This gift of his not just entertained me, it has also humbled me. It has taught me to worship (something I had thought I already knew how to do); reminded me why I am a Christian (which I didn’t think I had forgotten); and helped me prepare to die (which, paradoxically, causes me to feel intensely alive.)
How does he do this? Are there books he reads? Experts he consults? I rather think John is his own book, and his own expert, and that it is a gift from God.
Who else would think of using klezmer  music in the course of an Easter liturgy? This quintessentially Yiddish  music comes from the very exuberant, and utterly destroyed, Jewish culture of Eastern Europe before the Holocaust nightmare. When its exotic riffs burst out from among the rowdy lyrics I find myself leaping over the confines of conventional belief, dancing in a Sabbath chorus-line, dancing in defiance of demonic fascism and of death itself. And all that while sitting in my pew! When klezmer sounds forth at Christ Church Cranbrook, it is God who dances among the choir-pews.
Who else would think of having the male voices in a choir drone a solemn chord in the background while the women render psalm-verses in Gregorian chant? And then alternate the droning and the chant between the male and female voices, thus creating a Yin and Yang antiphony, an exquisite commentary on the harmony and agony of the world? John’s choral interpretations are part Benedictine monastery, part Lord of the Rings, calling us, Frodo-like, to suspend disbelief and see the world enchanted once again.
It could be that such things are done routinely elsewhere, but I think John has one ear tuned to ancient religious practices, and the other to the sound-track of tomorrow’s latest trend. For me, this results in a confluence of all that I most trust about the past, and all that I most enjoy about the present. Surrounded by John’s music, I become “open to the future”, a posture that the German theologian Rudolf Bultmann regarded as the closest our disenchanted age can come to what the apostolic church experienced on that first Easter.
Finally, who else would think to combine the sophisticated mechanics of a world-class pipe organ with the primal simplicity of bagpipes? There is no piece of religious music more familiar, or more often trivialized, than Amazing Grace. It has a special place in the mythology of my own family, and we sang it, plaintively, at both my parents’ burials at the Moravian Church cemetery in Canadensis, PA, while my mothers’ dogs lifted their grieving voices along with ours as we sang the hymn. Many years later, as John accompanied the bagpipes on the organ   the verses increased exponentially in volume, moving from a single bagpipe to a thunderous climax involving many pipers and every organ stop employed.
Was that John’s idea? I don’t know, but it was him playing the organ, and it brought me back to that Moravian cemetery  in the mountains, except that it was me who had died, and my children and dogs who sang.
I am sad about John’s leaving, and I am sad about the issues with his back that have kept him from playing the organ recently. I am sad about the deaths of my parents and my own inevitable end. But, as I contemplate these realities, I feel strangely and intensely alive. How strange is that?
It is strange in the way Easter is strange, the way the most familiar things can sometimes come as a surprise, the way silence merges with chant and becomes an unending hymn.
     

Monday, April 28, 2014

What's Up with "High" and "Low"?



WHAT’S UP WITH “HIGH CHURCH/LOW CHURCH”?
When my Virginia cousin Henry was in confirmation class in the 1950’s one of the questions raised by the students concerned the difference between “High Church” and “Low Church.” “That’s easy,” the teacher replied, “St. Thomas’ in Richmond is ‘Low Church.” What made it so? Because “any church that observes ‘Stonewall Jackson Sunday’ is Low Church.”
That may be one of the more eccentric definitions, but it serves to illustrate how much variety one may expect when exploring their meaning. In the 18th Century, “High Church” meant that you opposed doing anything to relax restrictions upon non-Anglican Protestants and Roman Catholics. In 1710 a mob were so inspired by a High Church sermon that they burned several Presbyterian chapels in London! During this period, “Low Church” meant you were Whig in your politics and kindly disposed to Protestants in general. By the 19th Century the “Low Church” had been energized by the Evangelical Movement inaugurated by John Wesley and others a century before, which emphasized personal conversion and holiness. Beginning with the “Oxford Movement” in 1833, the ‘High Church’ party (I am serious…they all spoke of their affiliations as “parties”) was inspired to emphasize the continuity of Anglicanism with the pre-reformation church. 

                                                      All Saints’ Margaret Street, London
                                                     
In the 1880’s a High Church Bishop in England was prosecuted for having lit candles on the altar during Holy Communion, while in the United States a group of High Church clergy left the Episcopal Church and became Roman Catholics because the General Convention approved the practice, on occasion, of allowing ministers of other denominations to preach in Episcopal pulpits. It is hard for us now to imagine why such commonplace things were major issues, which is the point I would like to make on this subject: the meaning of terms like “High” and “Low” has changed so much they have lost whatever meaning they may have once conveyed.  
                 
In the 1950’s, when I was being enculturated into the Episcopal Church, it was still common to hear such terms used, but they meant something very different from what they had in the 18th Century. The major division at that time was about the “centrality of the Eucharist.” If you had Holy Communion as the main service on most Sundays, you were more -or-less “High”. If you had Morning Prayer and Sermon on most Sundays, you were more-or-less “low.” All that changed in the 1970’s, when ordination of women was approved (1976), and a new Book of Common Prayer authorized (1979), and old affiliations dissolved and rearranged themselves around the new developments. Most of the women being ordained would be considered “High” by the old terminology, because they had not gone to the trouble of getting ordained as priests only to refrain from exercising their ministry at the altar.  Among the opponents of Women’s ordination were extremists from both the High and the Low ends of the spectrum. The result has been a new set of “parties” in the church, which have been described variously as “liberal”, “traditionalist”, “inclusive”, “orthodox”, and, as the humorous website “Ship of Fools” puts it, as “Stiff Upper Lip” or “Happy Clappy.”
The Diocese of Michigan, before the 1970’s, was known as “Low Church.” Today, that description would not apply to any church in the diocese. The only congregations in this diocese where the Eucharist is not the main service on Sunday are the ones where no priest is available to preside, and Morning Prayer is offered by lay persons. This consensus doesn’t mean there is no variety in worship: Christ Church Cranbrook is known for the “cathedral style” dignity and beauty of its liturgy and music, whereas the  
                                                                Happy Clappy?

Church of the Messiah in Detroit adheres to spirited “Black Church” norms of worship. At the same time, gospel music and other forms that might be considered “happy clappy” are regular features of worship at CCC and throughout the Episcopal Church.    
   If there is anything to be learned from this, it concerns the transitory nature of “parties” in the church and the limitations of partisanship in general. The fiercely contested issues of the past often seem trivial to us now, which ought to encourage a measure of humility in us, and a desire to cultivate “inquiring and discerning hearts” with regard to the issues of our own day. Reflection upon the past can sometimes reveal key moments when outspoken partisanship made a difference that still impacts our lives today. Such reflection can also reveal the way old controversies often synthesize into enduring assumptions accepted by nearly everyone.
What are the controversial issues of our own time that may have lasting consequences for future generations?